When the Things We Do to Feel Better Keep Us Stuck
Why short-term relief isn't always the same as long-term well-being

Have you ever spent a surprising amount of time preparing for a conversation you didn't want to have? Replayed something you said days ago, looking for evidence that you embarrassed yourself? Kept yourself so busy that, by the time you finally stopped, you were too exhausted to think about what was bothering you in the first place?
Or perhaps you've avoided making a decision, telling yourself you just needed a little more information. And then a little more.
These are all pretty ordinary human behaviours. Most of us have ways of managing uncomfortable thoughts and feelings: distraction, avoidance, reassurance, planning, or simply keeping busy.
And here's the thing: these strategies often work, at least in the short term.
Putting off a difficult conversation can reduce anxiety. Getting reassurance can ease uncertainty. Staying busy can keep painful thoughts at bay — at least for a while.
The question is whether that immediate relief is helping us in the longer term — or whether the things we do to cope might sometimes be keeping us stuck.
When coping becomes avoidance
In Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT), there's a concept called experiential avoidance. It describes efforts to escape, suppress, or control unwanted internal experiences — such as thoughts, emotions, memories, or bodily sensations — especially when those efforts become rigid and interfere with living meaningfully.
(It's worth clarifying that avoidance isn't inherently unhealthy, sometimes it's exactly what a situation calls for:
Taking a break from an argument before things escalate? Sensible.
Distracting yourself during a painful medical procedure? Useful.
Declining a social invitation because you're genuinely exhausted? Perfectly reasonable.)
The difficulty arises when avoiding discomfort becomes an automatic response, even when it conflicts with what matters to us.
And avoidance doesn't always look like avoidance.
Sometimes it looks like being exceptionally productive. You work, organise, clean, plan, and fill every available moment because being still means having to notice how you're feeling.
Sometimes it looks like being well-prepared. You analyse a situation from every possible angle, hoping that if you can just understand it well enough, the uncertainty will disappear.
Sometimes it looks like taking care of everyone else. You're the dependable one, the problem-solver, the person others turn to for support. Being useful to others may feel much more comfortable than acknowledging your own needs.
Or perhaps it looks like scrolling through your phone, watching another episode, having another drink, or putting something off until tomorrow.
What matters is the purpose it serves, how we use it, and what it costs us over time.
Why short-term relief can be so convincing
Imagine you're anxious about sending an important email.
You write it, reread it, change a few words, and then decide to leave it until tomorrow. Your anxiety drops. That relief may make postponing the next difficult email more tempting.
This is how negative reinforcement can work: Negative refers to the removal or avoidance of something unpleasant, while reinforcement means the behaviour becomes more likely to occur again. When a behaviour removes, prevents, or postpones something unpleasant, it may become more likely to happen again. The important part isn't simply that you felt relieved; it's that relief can help reinforce the habit of delaying.
In classical behaviourist experiments (think B.F. Skinner), animals learned to repeat behaviours that allowed them to escape or avoid something unpleasant, such as an electric shock. The same basic learning principle can apply to everyday situations: when delaying an email reduces anxiety, that relief can make delaying more likely the next time.
It's an understandable learning process. Immediate relief is easy to notice; the longer-term trade-offs can be harder to see.
Consider a few other examples:
You feel socially anxious, so you cancel plans. The anxiety may subside, but you also miss an opportunity for connection and for discovering that you might manage the situation better than expected.
You're afraid of making the wrong decision, so you keep researching. You may feel more prepared temporarily, but each new piece of information can raise another question.
You worry that someone is upset with you, so you repeatedly ask for reassurance. You feel better when they tell you everything is fine, but the next time uncertainty arises, you may feel you need reassurance again.
You avoid expressing disappointment because you dislike conflict. Things may stay peaceful on the surface, while resentment builds.
When relief repeatedly follows avoidance, these patterns can become self-reinforcing.
When avoiding uncertainty becomes a habit, we may miss opportunities to discover that we can cope with it. And when reassurance is our only way of handling doubt, we get less practice trusting our own judgement.
The more we organise our lives around avoiding uncomfortable feelings, the more those feelings can begin to dictate what we're willing to do.

The problem with control
ACT invites us to notice an important difference: solving a problem in the world isn't always the same as trying to eliminate our feelings about it.
There are plenty of things in life that benefit from problem-solving.
If you're struggling financially, developing a budget might help. If someone repeatedly crosses your boundaries, setting limits may be necessary. If you're overwhelmed with responsibilities, asking for help or changing your circumstances could make a meaningful difference.
Acceptance doesn't mean passivity, and psychological flexibility certainly doesn't mean tolerating mistreatment. Nor does ACT suggest that every attempt to soothe ourselves is a problem.
But emotions and thoughts don't always respond to the same strategies that work for practical problems. In a sense, the world outside us and the world inside us operate by different rules. In the external world, control and problem-solving are often effective. If something is broken, we try to fix it. If there's a problem, we look for a solution.
But our internal world isn't working with the same parameters Trying to get rid of an unwanted thought can make it more noticeable. This is famously illustrated by Daniel Wegner's famous white bear experiments, in which people instructed not to think about a white bear struggled to keep the thought out of their minds. Struggling to suppress anxiety can sometimes add another layer of distress. And the harder we try to force ourselves to feel a certain way, the more frustrated we may become when our emotions don't cooperate.
The problem arises when we apply the same control strategies to our inner experiences that work so well in the world around us. What helps us solve an external problem doesn't necessarily help us relate to an uncomfortable thought or feeling.
You can make a spreadsheet to manage your finances. You can't necessarily make one that guarantees you'll never feel anxious about money again, although some of us might give it a fairly determined try.
We often approach uncomfortable emotions as problems that need to be solved before we can move forward.
I'll apply for that job when I feel more confident.
I'll have that conversation when I'm less anxious.
I'll make a decision once I'm completely sure.
I'll start doing things differently when I'm ready.
These conditions sound reasonable, but they can become moving targets.
Confidence may not arrive before we take action. Certainty may remain elusive no matter how much information we gather. And feeling ready isn't always a prerequisite for doing something meaningful.
The alternative isn't to force ourselves through every uncomfortable situation. It's to develop a different relationship with discomfort, one in which our feelings can inform our choices without necessarily making them for us.

When our world starts getting smaller
One of the consequences of experiential avoidance is that its impact can accumulate gradually.
Someone who avoids speaking up in meetings because they're afraid of looking foolish may eventually stop contributing altogether, despite having valuable ideas.
Someone who avoids difficult conversations to protect their relationships may find themselves feeling increasingly disconnected from the people they care about.
Someone who relies heavily on reassurance may find that it becomes less effective, while their confidence in making independent decisions diminishes.
And someone who manages emotional discomfort by staying busy may become remarkably effective at getting things done while feeling increasingly disconnected from themselves.
Often, the strategies that initially helped us navigate a difficult period simply continue operating long after they've stopped being useful.
We may not even notice the trade-off.
We're avoiding anxiety, but also avoiding opportunities.
We're protecting ourselves from rejection, but also limiting connection.
We're trying not to feel inadequate, but never giving ourselves the chance to learn
that we can handle making mistakes.
The problem isn't that we sometimes choose comfort. Who wouldn't? It's when avoiding discomfort starts determining the boundaries of our lives.
A different question: Is this helping me build the life I want?
Much of our behaviour is guided by an understandable question:
What can I do to feel better right now?
ACT encourages us to consider another:
Is what I'm doing helping me build the life I want to live?
This changes what we're evaluating.
Instead of judging a strategy solely by how effectively it reduces distress, we look at whether it helps us move toward what's important to us.
This brings us to another central ACT concept: values.
Values are the qualities we want to bring to our actions and relationships. Things like honesty, curiosity, compassion, learning, connection, courage, and responsibility.
Unlike goals, they aren't things we complete and cross off a list.
You might have a goal of reconnecting with an old friend. The underlying value could be maintaining meaningful relationships.
You might have a goal of applying for a new position. The value might be growth, learning, or contributing through your work.
You might want to have a difficult conversation with your partner. The underlying value could be honesty or mutual respect.
Values help us make choices that aren't exclusively determined by how we happen to feel in a particular moment.
For example, reaching out to a friend may bring up anxiety about rejection. If connection matters to you, you might decide to send the message anyway.
Not because you've eliminated the anxiety, but because you've decided that making room for connection is worth some uncertainty.
This is an important distinction. We don't necessarily have to feel better before we can start doing things that matter to us.
And sometimes, taking those steps changes how we feel along the way.
Is facing discomfort always the right choice?
Some situations really are unsafe. Some relationships require firmer boundaries rather than greater openness. Sometimes we're exhausted, overwhelmed, grieving, or simply not in a position to take on another challenge.
And sometimes avoiding or postponing something is a thoughtful, values-consistent choice.
The aim is not to eliminate avoidance from our lives. It's to become more deliberate about when we use it.
There is a meaningful difference between choosing to rest because you need recovery and withdrawing from activities because you're afraid of feeling inadequate.
There is a difference between taking time to prepare for something important and preparing indefinitely because you can't tolerate the possibility of making a mistake.
The same behaviour can serve very different functions, depending on the context.
ACT refers to the capacity to respond to these situations with greater awareness and flexibility as psychological flexibility.
In everyday terms, it means being able to notice what you're thinking and feeling, consider the circumstances, and choose how to respond rather than operating entirely on autopilot.
It doesn't mean always making the boldest decision. It means having more room to choose.
Putting it into practice: A brief exercise
The next time you notice yourself avoiding something, seeking reassurance, overpreparing, or trying to distract yourself from an uncomfortable feeling, try getting curious about what's happening.
You don't need to change anything immediately.
1. Notice what you're experiencing
What thoughts, emotions, or sensations are showing up?
Perhaps you're anxious about disappointing someone, embarrassed about something you said, or worried about making a mistake.
Try naming the experience without immediately trying to fix it.
I'm noticing anxiety.
I'm having the thought that I'm going to fail.
I'm feeling the urge to withdraw.
Naming an experience like this may create a little distance between having it and automatically responding to it.
2. Identify what you're doing to manage it
Are you putting something off? Looking for reassurance? Replaying conversations? Distracting yourself? Trying to anticipate every possible outcome?
There is no need to criticise yourself for any of it.
Simply notice the strategy.
3. Consider what the strategy gives you
What happens in the short term when you use it?
Maybe you feel calmer, safer, more prepared, or less exposed.
Acknowledging that benefit matters. Understanding what keeps a strategy going is often more useful than criticising yourself for using it.
4. Look at the longer-term consequences
If you continue responding this way over the next few months, what might happen?
Is the strategy helping you deal with a genuine problem? Is it giving you necessary rest or protection?
Or could it be preventing you from building confidence, developing relationships, making decisions, or pursuing something you care about?
You might discover that the strategy is useful and worth keeping. Or you might notice that the relief comes with a cost you're no longer comfortable paying.
5. Choose one small step
If you decide you'd like to respond differently, start small.
For example:
If you've been avoiding a difficult conversation, you might begin by identifying one thing you'd like to communicate clearly.
If you're repeatedly seeking reassurance about a low-stakes uncertainty, you might experiment with tolerating a little doubt before asking someone else for their opinion.
If you're overpreparing, you might set a reasonable time limit and practise moving forward with an imperfect result.
If you've been avoiding social activities, you could try attending something brief rather than committing to an entire evening.
If you tend to distract yourself whenever difficult feelings arise, you might take a minute to notice what you're experiencing before reaching for your phone.
The idea is to practise responding in ways that are consistent with what matters to you, even when the experience isn't entirely comfortable.
Think of it as doing the reps. Just as physical strength develops through repeated practice, psychological flexibility can grow through small, repeated choices to act in line with your values, even when uncomfortable thoughts and feelings show up.
Choose steps that are reasonably safe and suited to your circumstances. If a step feels too difficult, that's useful information too: you can make it smaller, approach it differently, or seek additional support.
Making room for a fuller life
There is nothing wrong with wanting relief from distress. We all need comfort, rest, predictability, and ways to regulate difficult emotions.
The problem comes when relief becomes our main modus operandi for navigating life.
When that happens, we can spend so much energy trying not to feel anxious, embarrassed, rejected, uncertain, or disappointed that we have less energy left for the things that make life meaningful.
ACT offers a different approach. Rather than treating every uncomfortable internal experience as something that must be eliminated, we can learn to make room for those experiences while choosing actions that reflect our values.
This doesn't mean ignoring our emotions. It means taking them seriously without assuming they always need to determine our behaviour.
So the next time you find yourself reaching for a familiar coping strategy, consider asking yourself two questions:
Is this helping me feel better right now?
And is it helping me move toward the kind of life I want to live?
This article is for general educational purposes and isn't a substitute for individualised mental health care. If anxiety, depression, trauma-related distress, or avoidance is significantly affecting your daily life, a qualified mental health professional can help you explore these patterns safely and at your own pace. You don't need to push yourself into situations that are unsafe or overwhelming.
Further reading
Association for Contextual Behavioral Science: About ACT — an overview of ACT and psychological flexibility.
APA Dictionary of Psychology: Negative reinforcement — a concise definition of the learning process discussed above.
Akbari et al. (2022): Systematic review and meta-analysis of experiential avoidance — research on associations between experiential avoidance and psychological symptoms; association does not, by itself, establish causation.



Comments